1. SUBTITLE
A continuity from pre-patriarchal time until the
present day. A proposal for scientific research.
2. BRIEF DESCRIPTION
My research is divided in five main chapters:
+ The
universal Great Mother and her hero
+ The process of restoring the old religion
+ Its implications for society
+ The special position of Tao Te Ching: not the beginning,
but the closure of an era
+ The continuity of folk religion from pre-patriarchial times until present days
In the first chapter the original myth of
pre-patriarchal time will be elaborated, in which the Source of the universe is being
depicted as a Womb, a Vacuum from which the Divine the Light is emerging. In
Chinese mythology this is symbolized by the Great Mother sending her messengers
with Maitreya Buddha as the most prominent one to the earth in order to save
mankind. Through comparative research traces of the original myth will be collected both
from various ancient civilizations as well as those from China, the latter a.o. derived
from a large series of Chinese folk religious texts, the so-called pao-chüan or
precious volumes. In the second chapter these texts will serve as a source to
describe the attempts of restoring the old religion a.o. against the background of
the pressure of the surrounding dominant patriarchal society. In the third chapter both
the role of women and the claim on hegemony are the central issues, like women and
Enlightenment and Maitreya as the savior and revolutionary. In the forth chapter the Tao
Te Ching will be looked at in its original meaning. Finally, an attempt will be made to
prove the continuity of folk religion from pre-patriarchal times until present days.
3. CENTRAL
PROPOSITION
The central proposition is to show, that
pre-patriarchal religious myths have survived until the present day and their possible
value for modern society. To talk about pre-patriarchal time is difficult,
since written texts only start with the great wise men. The Tao Te Ching plays
a key role here though. It is an attempt to restore the original (pre-patriarchal)
tradition with corresponding insights into that era. (It can be considered as the
closure of the previous era, rather than the beginning of a new). The book very much
underlines the interpretation which I try to emphasize in this thesis.
4. KEY
QUESTION TO BE ANSWERED
The central question to be answered is: Is
there a continuity in religious tradition from pre-patriarchal times until the present
day? Sub-questions are: Does comparing creation myths from around the world
with those from China have any validity? and Do the pao-chüan texts in any
way relate to those original myths and if yes, how?
5.
RELATIONSHIP WITH THE PRESENT STATE OF RESEARCH
Current research is mainly discussing the phenomenon
- the pao-chüan texts with their corresponding sects - as such, or its relationship to
its actual surrounding dominant patriarchal environment. Usually, the former is considered
to be a reaction to the latter. My study, however, is trying to prove the relationship
between the texts and pre-patriarchal time, while considering the actual situation merely
as a trigger. While existing studies are diagnosing the rising of sects as attempts
to create new religions, my research on the other hand is interpreting the
same phenomenon as an attempt consciously or unconsciously - to restore the
old pre-patriarchal religion.
6. MAIN
THEORETICAL CONCEPTS AND SCHOLARS
The guidelines along which I hope to develop my
thesis are fourfold. They include: a. The continuity of religious folk beliefs, myths and
concepts throughout the ages, despite their changing appearances; b. The interaction of a
particular phenomenon with its context, both actual, historical and with regard to inner
religious life; c. The concept of society as a process of dialectic dynamism between the
dominant minority and the (suppressed) majority; d. Culture as a phenomenon of continuous
decay, permanence and recovery. With regard to the methodology I am favoring an optimum
between empirism and hermeneutics, keeping in mind what my most revered teacher has said:
My primary methodological concern is to avoid reductionism as much as possible, that
is, to meet the subject in question at every level on which it presents itself, without
distortion. (Overmyer, D.L. Folk Buddhist Religion. Harvard East Asian Series 83),
1976. Interpreting phenomena in their original context, trying to give them their original
meaning back, will be a major task. Besides Daniel L. Overmyer I am indebted to J.J.M.De
Groot, R.Chu, C.K.Yang, Chuang Chi-ga, Che His-lun and others.
7. SEEKING
MY PROMOTORS, I.E. SUPERVISION COMMITTEE
My favorite option would be to find an optimal
environment in which I would be able to fully develop the power of my thesis. More in
particular I am seeking a university, i.e. a department and a promoter, who are
specialized in either Chinese folk religion, e.g. pao-chüan literature or/and women
studies. Because of the character of my approach religious, historic, cultural,
social and women I would like to be able to choose co-promoters from various
disciplines.
8. SOURCES,
I.E. EMPIRICAL DATA
The available sources can be divided in seven
different categories: a. Literature about archaic, i.e. creation myths from around the
world; b. Women studies about pre-patriarchal cultures; c. The Tao Te Ching d. The
historic documents of pao-chüan literature with emphasis on the role of the Great Mother
(Wu-Sheng lao mu) and Maitreya Buddha respectively, divided into at least twenty big
volumes, each containing many sub-chapters (in Chinese); e. The interpretation of those
texts by a number of Chinese scholars, f.e. Tseng Tsu-liang, Chuang Chi-ga, Wang Hsi-yuan
and Che Hsi lun (in Chinese); f. Books written by renowned scholars, like J.J.M. De
Groot and others as mentioned above, with special emphasis on the publications of Daniel
L. Overmyer; g. The few theses available on this subject, like that of Chuang Chi-ga.
9. ACCESS
TO SOURCES
All necessary sources are available, from the
library of the Sinological Institute in Leiden (NL), the Columbia University Library (USA)
to the National Library of China in Beijing (PRC), Shanghai Public Library, Soochow
University, various sources on Taiwan, like reprints by the Min-te tang temple in
Taichung, Taiwan, besides common sources all over the world and the internet. The
collection of pao-chüan texts of Prof.dr.Daniel L. Overmyer seems to be most complete
though. I will certainly ask Mr. Overmyer to what extent his collection is available for
the purpose of my research.
10.
SIGNIFICANCE I.E. RELEVANCE
With regard to my own scientific field the thesis is
a major extension of the scope of interest, extending Chinese folk religion to its
original roots. Usually, studies like this (and others) are limiting themselves to sources
from after the rise of patriarchy only. My study, however, goes beyond. Furthermore, its
social significance may lay in the fact, that by connecting religion to its
pre-patriarchal origins, a glimpse of a feminine world view may become
visible. Since institutions of a particular society are reflecting the underlying world
view, which in their turn are largely related to religious and philosophical pre-concepts,
changing them changes the very foundation on which such a society is built. In our society
such a change is not only desirable, but a matter of sheer survival.
11.
PRACTICALITIES
My background includes MA Social Science (Regional
Development) at the ISS (Institute of Social Science) in The Hague, The Netherlands. Since
then (1993) I have been pursuing a career as a therapist and teacher in Traditional
Chinese Medicine with a full operating clinic since 1999. My combined interest in
religion, Chinese culture, women studies and their social relevance, made me decide to
resume my studies. However, I am still at the very beginning of my re-orientation in the
academic field. At the moment I am involved in getting together the most relevant
priorities, like a team of promoters, a scholarship, a supervisor and a university.
12.
RELEVANT PUBLICATIONS
Besides above mentioned Chinese sources a provisional bibliography
includes:
De Groot , J. J. M. The Religious System of China. 6 vols. Leiden, E. J. Brill,
1892-1910
---------- Sectarianism and Religious Persecution in China.
2 vols. Amsterdam, Johannes Muller, 1903
Thompson, L. G. Chinese Religion. Belmont. Wadsworth, 1979
Overmyer, D. L. Folk Buddhist Religion. Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1976
Jordan, D. K. and Overmyer, D. L. The Flying Phoenix, Aspects of Chinese Sectarianism in
Taiwan. New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 1986.
Overmyer, D. L. Precious Volumes, An Introduction to Chinese Sectarian Scriptures from the
Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. Cambridge, 1999.
Overmyer, D. L. Messenger, Savior, Revolutionary, Maitreya in Chinese Popular Religious
Literature of Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. In Sponberg and Hardacre, H. Maitreya,
The Future Buddha, Cambridge University Press, 1988
Gia-Fu Feng and English, J. Lao Tsu, Tao Te Ching. London, Wildwood House, 1978.
Chun-Fang Yü. Kuan Yin. New York, Columbia University Press, 2001.
Toynbee, A. J. A Study of History. New York, Oxford University Press, 1947.
Neumann, E. The Great Mother. New York, Princeton University Press, 1963
Bachofen, J. J. Myth, Religion, & Mother Right. New York, Princeton University Press,
1967
Sered, S. S. Priestess, Mother, Sacred Sister, Religions Dominated by Women. New York,
Oxford University Press, 1994
Lerner, G. The Creation of Patriarchy. New York, Oxford University Press, 1986
Werlhof, C. Von. MutterLos. Munich, Frauenoffensive, 1996
Goettner-Abendroth, H, Die Goettin und Ihr Heros. Munich, Frauenoffensive, 1997
Mei Yu, M.A. |